But What If? How to Stop Overthinking
Updated: Oct 19
Have you ever replayed a conversation in your head for the tenth time, wondering whether you said the wrong thing? Or spent hours trying to make a decision, convinced that if you just thought about it a little longer, you'd finally feel certain? Welcome to overthinking.
We are all too familiar with the cycle of doubt and questioning ourselves. While it may feel productive to run through each and every possible scenario, we aren't actually getting anywhere. If I keep thinking about what to do, I won't actually have to do it.
What is Overthinking?
Overthinking is a general term for getting stuck repeatedly thinking about the same problem, situation, decision, or possibility. We're replaying something that already happened or trying to predict something that hasn't happened yet.
One form of overthinking is rumination. Rumination involves repeatedly going over thoughts, events, or feelings, often without reaching a useful conclusion.
You might find yourself asking:
Why did I say that?
What if I made the wrong decision?
What if they are upset with me?
Why can't I just get over this?
What should I have done differently?
What if something goes wrong?
At first, these questions can seem like problem-solving. But eventually, you may notice that you're asking the same questions without finding any new answers. That's when thinking can turn into a cycle.
The Overthinking Cycle
Overthinking often follows a pattern: Triggers lead to thoughts, thoughts lead to uncertainty, uncertainty leads to analysis. The analysis actually provides us temorary relief, letting us believe we are understanding more and more about the problem we are facing. That is until the doubt sets in, leading to more analysis, and repeat.
For example, imagine you send a message to a friend and they don't respond.
You might initially think: "They're probably busy."
Then uncertainty creeps in: "What if they're annoyed with me?"
You start reviewing the conversation: "Did I say something weird?"
You reread your messages, then think about previous interactions, then you imagine different explainations.
Eventually, you may feel like you've done something useful because you've thoroughly analyzed the situation. But then another possibility appears and the cycle starts again.
The problem is that thinking cannot always provide the certainty we're looking for.
Why is it so Difficult to Stop Overthinking?
Overthinking often has a purpose. Your brain may be trying to protect you. If you can anticipate every possible problem, maybe you can prevent something bad from happening. If you analyze a conversation enough, maybe you can figure out exactly what someone thinks of you. If you think through every possible outcome, maybe you can guarantee that you'll make the right decision.
The difficulty is that life doesn't offer that kind of certainty. No amount of thinking can completely eliminate uncertainty. And when we use thinking to try to achieve certainty, we can accidentally teach our brains: "I need to keep thinking until I feel completely sure." Unfortunately, that feeling of certainty may never arrive.
Thinking vs. Problem-Solving
Overthinking is a signal with the belief that something bad is coming. In that moment, what we need is safety. If thinking is the problem, action is the solution. The goal is not to control the thoughts or even get rid of them, it is to change the relationship we have with them.
Ask yourself: Is there something I can actually do about this right now?
If the answer is yes, identify one small action.
If the answer is no, remind yourself: "I can't solve something that there is no solution for at this time."
This doesn't mean ignoring the problem. It means recognizing when thinking has stopped being useful.
When Overthinking Starts Getting in the Way
Everyone overthinks sometimes. But if rumination is taking up a significant amount of your time, interfering with sleep, affecting your relationships, or making it difficult to enjoy your life, it may be worth exploring in therapy.
Therapy can help you understand why your mind gets caught in these loops, what keeps the cycle going, and how to respond differently when it happens. You don't have to wait until your thoughts become completely overwhelming before reaching out for support.




Comments